City of Caldwell and former CPD officer reach $1.5M settlement
May 21, 2026
Former Caldwell Police Department (CPD) officer Allison Butler and the City of Caldwell, Caldwell Police Chief Rex Ingram, and former Caldwell Mayor Jarom Wagoner have settled a lawsuit brought by Butler, which alleged instances
of gender-based discrimination, harassment, and retaliation during her time with CPD.According to a statement from Birch Hallam Harstad Johnson, the law firm representing Butler, the plaintiff agreed to drop the lawsuit "in exchange for $1,500,000 and significant non-monetary relief aimed at clearing her good name and reputation as a dedicated law enforcement officer at Caldwell Police Department.""The parties are glad they could reach a resolution," reads a news release from the City of Caldwell.In response to questions from Idaho News 6, a spokesperson for the City of Caldwell stated, The City confirms that a settlement has been reached in this matter. The City, as always, will remain focused on fulfilling its mission to serve the Caldwell community to the best of its ability.PREVIOUS COVERAGE | Caldwell officer files amended discrimination complaint, adding Mayor WagonerThe plaintiff's law firm goes on to state: "The City had a chance to do the right thing when it received the investigation report from Doug Plass, an outside attorney investigator. Instead, the City buried the Plass report, ignored its HR Directors recommendations, and gave the Chief minor discipline for just two of the alleged events. All this left Officer Butler exposed to further harassment and retaliation which ended her career at CPD." In a statement, Butler said, I have faith that the City, under Mayor Eric Phillips, will honor the law and ensure that reports about harassment, discrimination and retaliation are taken seriously even when it implicates the leadership at the top. I am glad that City Council now has the full Plass report. Going forward, I hope they will take appropriate steps to prevent future harassment and retaliation. My former fellow CPD officers, who work tirelessly to make Caldwell a safer community, deserve nothing less.We also reached out to Chief Rex Ingram and received this statement: The decision to settle this civil matter was made by the insurance carrier. This settlement included no admission of liability, fault, or wrongdoing on my part or that of the Caldwell Police Department. And I strongly deny any wrongdoing.The insurer has resolved the civil claim, and the case is concluded. We are moving forward. My focus remains exactly where it belongs: leading the dedicated men and women of the CPD, maintaining institutional accountability, and ensuring the safety of the Caldwell community. I am proud of the men and women of my department who have dedicated their lives to protecting and serving our community."This marks the third settlement involving Caldwell Police Chief Rex Ingram.Idaho News 6 has reached out to Chief Ingram and the attorneys representing the City of Caldwell. As of this writing, Idaho News 6 has yet to receive responses.For Canyon County happenings, news, and more join our Facebook Group: 2C Neighborhood News - Nampa, Caldwell, Middleton
...read more
read less