Coloradans rack up costly car repairs from contaminated gas
Jan 15, 2026
Hundreds of Coloradans are facing unexpected and costly car troubles after a fuel supplier distributed contaminated gas to 46 stations across metro Denver, ranging from Fort Collins to Colorado Springs.
Colorado’s Department of Labor and Employment, which includes the Division of Oil and Public Sa
fety, received more than 600 complaints from customers who bought gas contaminated with diesel that was delivered from an HR Sinclair terminal in Henderson on Jan. 8 and 9.
Sinclair officials this week apologized and said they are investigating how the problem happened – which was not enough to ward off a proposed class action lawsuit filed by Littleton resident Ryan Mahon, who purchased 28 gallons for his Toyota Tundra from the Costco gas station in Englewood on Jan. 8.
Kyle O’Brien, another metro Denver driver impacted by the contaminated fuel, got gas at the Costco near his home in Westminster early on Jan. 8 before driving his truck to work in Commerce City.
“I got to work just fine and went to leave at 4 (p.m.) and it started really weak,” O’Brien said. “When I went to put it in drive, the engine just shut off.”
O’Brien tried to figure out what was wrong by looking under the hood and checking the battery. He tried starting the truck again to find it was idling “wonky,” so he cleaned the throttle body, which seemed to help a little, and drove home.
He made it back to Westminster after dealing with poor acceleration and more weird idling and tried to clean the mass air flow sensor before he called it a night. That’s when he saw news articles reporting the rash of contaminated gas across metro Denver.
“I couldn’t help but laugh because at least it’s not something serious,” O’Brien said. “It’s not great, but at least the engine doesn’t need to be replaced.”
O’Brien had his car towed to a shop near Costco and went to speak with a manager at the warehouse store, who immediately started working on his case. Costco is reimbursing his expenses – about $1,300 to drain and clean his truck’s tank and fuel line — but he had to pay for the up-front cost out of his own pocket.
Related Articles
Class action lawsuit proposed in Denver over contaminated gas
Bill would exempt municipal utilities from 2030 state emissions target
List: Here are the Colorado gas stations that pumped contaminated gas
Over 400 consumers file complaints over contaminated fuel at Denver-area gas stations
Aurora neighborhood claims victory — for now — in halting 32 oil and gas wells near reservoir
O’Brien added he’s impressed by how Costco has handled the situation and that the company has been on top of taking care of impacted customers.
“I feel bad for people who just got it from a random gas station,” O’Brien said.
Dealing with repairs because of the contaminated gas? Share your story with The Denver Post by contacting reporter Katie Langford at [email protected].
This is a developing story and may be updated.
Get more Colorado news by signing up for our daily Your Morning Dozen email newsletter.
...read more
read less